CSK Defense
Orlando Partner Scott Shelton
Case Summary
This case arose from a motor vehicle collision that led to a negligence lawsuit involving allegations of significant injuries and substantial damages. The lawsuit was brought against the Defendant driver and vehicle owner. Although liability was admitted, the Plaintiff alleged injuries requiring extensive medical treatment, including injections and recommendations for future surgery.
Plaintiff sought more than $15 million in damages for ongoing pain and suffering, past lost wages, loss of future earning capacity, and anticipated medical expenses. The case was transferred to the defense approximately six months before trial, with the primary dispute centered on the extent and value of the Plaintiff's claimed injuries.
Defense Strategy
The defense focused on challenging the extent of the Plaintiff's alleged damages through cross-examination, without presenting independent expert testimony. By closely examining the Plaintiff's medical records, treatment history, and witness testimony, we questioned whether the evidence supported the substantial compensation requested.
Outcome
Following approximately three hours of deliberation, the jury awarded $125,000 in damages, substantially less than the Plaintiff's demand of more than $15 million.
The result highlights the importance of carefully examining damages evidence and demonstrates how focused cross-examination can significantly limit exposure in cases involving admitted liability and substantial compensation demands.
Our team is available to discuss the topics written here and ready to provide additional information contained in this article. Contact us for more information.
