CSK Appellate Counsel
Orlando Associate Michael Andriano
Case Summary
This case arose from a motor vehicle negligence lawsuit involving disputed injuries and medical causation in 2024. CSK represented the Defendant insurance company, which received a favorable jury verdict after the jury determined that the accident was not the legal cause of the Plaintiff's claimed injuries or damages.
Following the verdict, the Plaintiff appealed several trial court rulings, including the directed verdict on certain issues, the refusal to provide a jury instruction concerning the aggravation of a preexisting medical condition, and the exclusion of evidence related to vehicle repairs.
Appellate Strategy
On appeal, Mr. Andriano defended the trial court's rulings, addressing issues involving medical causation, evidentiary sufficiency, jury instructions, and the preservation of arguments for appellate review.
During oral argument, he responded to arguments raised by opposing counsel that had not been developed in the initial appellate briefing. He also maintained that any alleged trial court errors were harmless and did not warrant reversal of the judgment.
Outcome
The Fifth District Court of Appeal issued a per curiam affirmance, leaving intact the unanimous defense verdict and final judgment in favor of the Defendant insurance company. The ruling preserved the jury's determination that the accident was not the legal cause of the Plaintiff's claimed injuries or damages.
Our team is available to discuss the topics written here and ready to provide additional information contained in this article. Contact us for more information.