CSK Defense Team
Miami Partner George Hooker
Miami Associate Elizabeth Keck
Case Summary
This case arose from a first party property insurance dispute involving alleged damage caused by Hurricane Ian. The Plaintiffs claimed that the hurricane created an opening in their roof, resulting in interior water intrusion and necessitating a full roof replacement.
The dispute centered on whether the property sustained a direct physical loss caused by a windstorm during the policy period.
Defense Strategy
The CSK Defense Team challenged the Plaintiffs' claims by presenting expert testimony demonstrating that the roof conditions were consistent with long-term deterioration, inadequate maintenance, and age-related wear rather than hurricane-related damage.
The Team also introduced weather data showing that other storms before and after Hurricane Ian produced comparable or greater wind speeds, challenging the Plaintiffs' assertion that the damage resulted specifically from the hurricane.
Outcome
Following a two-day trial and approximately twenty minutes of deliberation, the jury returned a complete defense verdict, finding that the Plaintiffs failed to establish a covered windstorm loss under the policy.
The result highlights the importance of evaluating causation in first party property insurance disputes and demonstrates the value of expert testimony and objective weather evidence in assessing storm-related damage claims.
Our team is available to discuss the topics written here and ready to provide additional information contained in this article. Contact us for more information.