CSK Defense Team
Jacksonville Partner Victoria Merritt
Orlando Partner Scott Shelton
Case Summary
A four‑day trial in Duval County centered on Plaintiff seeking significant damages after a vehicle collision caused by a Defendant who admitted fault. The Plaintiff claimed serious shoulder, neck and back injuries, underwent shoulder surgery, and presented approximately $63,000 in past medical expenses, along with more than $800,000 in projected future care to include neck and back surgeries, in this post tort reform case.
Defense Strategy
The CSK Defense Team focused on the minimal nature of the accident, Plaintiff’s medical history which was not fully disclosed to her medical providers, and the bias involved with Plaintiff’s post-incident medical providers. By dissecting the medical records, questioning the life care projections, reducing boardable meds to reasonable rate per tort reform, and emphasizing the lack of objective support for long‑term impairment, the defense positioned the jury to view the Plaintiff’s damages demand as inflated and unsupported.
Outcome
The jury returned a defense verdict—covering past medical bills and a small fraction of the requested amount for future care—while rejecting the claims of permanent injury. This amount was just above the amount suggested by the defense during closing arguments. The outcome underscores the power of a targeted defense strategy: jurors responded to clear, concise evidence, were unpersuaded by expansive medical projections, and ultimately embraced a practical, fact‑based assessment of damages. It stands as a strong reminder that a well‑executed defense can significantly limit exposure, even in cases involving admitted liability and substantial medical claims.
Our team is available to discuss the topics written here and ready to provide additional information contained in this article. Contact us for more information.
